I really like the way the post processing looks in the mirror, but pretty much can't stand it everywhere else on the image--it just looks a little bit too cartoony. I feel this image lacks a deliberate reasoning for the extreme post processing.

I think we've all been there, done that.

I feel like the extra processing doesn't fit with the photo. To me this looks like a somewhat normal shot in a car mirror with some added creepy effects put on top. The "creepiness" of the processing doesn't really fit with the "normalness" of the photo. Hopefully that makes sense.

I really like the treatment on this. The hand in the foreground is a bit distracting from the reflection in the mirror but overall, I like the image.

I think this has been overworked and has lost meaning.

I think there was too much post processing done on this photo. I know it's hard to come up with unique shots but I think it was overdone.